Is the new Google+ redesign working?

Warning: this content is older than 365 days. It may be out of date and no longer relevant.

One of the questions that came up immediately after Google+ redesigned its interface was whether people liked it. Whether someone likes it or not is an exceptionally subjective question, and one that is very hard to analyze without a ton of primary research. The more important question I had was this: does the new redesign accomplish the goal of getting more people to a website?

The Methodology

In order to answer this, I needed to do some apples-to-apples comparisons. Fortunately, as someone who’s done a bit of consulting here and there, I am privileged to have access to a bunch of people’s Google Analytics data, so I was able to look at 5 different kinds of website to answer my question, all of which are very active in social media. The five sites I picked were:

  • Mine. (obviously) with about 20,000 unique visitors a month.
  • A B2B site with about 25,000 unique visitors a month.
  • A B2C media site with 1.5 million unique visitors a month.
  • Marketing Over Coffee, a B2B media site with about 3,000 unique visitors a month.
  • A B2C retail site with about 2,000 unique visitors a month.

I picked two control periods and a test period to look at the data. Control period 1 was 3/28-4/4, the Wednesday to Wednesday period prior to the Google+ UI change. Control period 2 was 3/14-3/21, the Wednesday to Wednesday period which corresponded to the same period in March that the post-change period was in April. The post-change period was 4/11-4/18, Wednesday to Wednesday.

In order to establish a benchmark that wasn’t purely a Google+ vacuum, I also pulled the Facebook data for those 5 sites and put that data side by side. After all the data collection was done, I averaged the two control periods together to smooth out any major spikes that might have been anomalies.

The specific metric chosen was percentage of site traffic; that is, if 1 out of 100 visitors to my site came from Google+, that was 1% of site traffic.

The Results

Here’s Google+:

Google+ Redesign: G+ Data

My personal website is the anomaly; the other sites showed marked declines in visitors from Google+ over the averaged control period vs. the period after the redesign, with the exception of the retail site which was more or less static. If you average it out, these sites lost 23.5% traffic from their Google+ audience since the redesign.

Let’s look at Facebook now. If there was something bigger going on that impacted these sites as a whole, we should see about a 23.5% loss in Facebook traffic as well. Survey says:

Google+ Redesign: Facebook Data

The only consistent site that showed a similar loss over the same period was the B2B site. The rest (except for mine, which is apparently just weird and contrarian) showed increases in Facebook traffic from the same time period. If you average it out, these sites gained 159% more traffic from their Facebook audience in the same time period as the Google+ redesign.

The Conclusion

Based on what I’ve seen from the sites above, the Google+ redesign did not impact the majority of sites positively in terms of a marketing metric that matters – visitors to the site. Whether or not I like the new UI personally, it’s not working in a major way for 3 of the 5 sites that I examined in this early result.

The thing to do next is to wait some more and examine the data again in a month and in two months to see if traffic and performance returns to the previous baseline once people have gotten used to the new interface. This is not a call to stop using Google+ or start using Facebook more, not yet. It is a call to say that you should be examining your own data in your own analytics software to see if the results you are getting are similar or different.

If, after a month of solid data, we see similar patterns, then there may indeed be a persistent problem with the new Google+ interface. The early data is not encouraging. Stay tuned.

You might also enjoy:

Want to read more like this from Christopher Penn? Get updates here:

subscribe to my newsletter here

AI for Marketers Book
Take my Generative AI for Marketers course!

Analytics for Marketers Discussion Group
Join my Analytics for Marketers Slack Group!


6 responses to “Is the new Google+ redesign working?”

  1. I suspected as such when the redesign came out. I don’t have any data to back it up, but I feel like I am getting a lot less engagement and interaction on G+ than I was before the redesign (notably, the opposite with Facebook…)

    1. Agreed. Time will tell as we get more data, and next time I’ll add in absolute data n umbers too.

  2. Great job at taking an analytical approach to this particular question. I have also been curious as to what the impact would be, however, I have not been able to make a conclusion. 

    Great work @cspenn:disqus 

  3. Do you know what happened with Google+ traffic during the after period? I wonder if it’s possible that people simply avoided G+ for a little while and instead spent their time on Facebook? As you said, following up in a few months should identify that pretty clearly.

  4. yoursocial fans Avatar
    yoursocial fans

    Buy Facebook
    Fans to Raise Website Traffic @ YourSocialFans.Com

    Facebook is one of the usually social websites in a present
    world. You will be able to Buy search engines plus from the innovative
    manufacturers. They will be extremely dedicated into introducing every one of
    the purchasers using the best facebook blowers web page. They make an
    impossible face-book tag in the fan web page website. This is often designed by
    the use of the iframe situation. There are so many issues designed. A few of
    them could be the ad images; add facebook blowers, customized tabs and many
    other things. Buy Facebook Fans therefore you will making your facebook fanpage
    look completely exclusive and exciting. 

  5. Hello Christopher,

    Great research! I just want to share my personal research regarding Google+. Well, for the past few months, I’ve only been doing Google+ for my site as it’s social media promotion. It has greatly increased my traffic as well as rankings on specific keywords. However, I still couldn’t conclude that it is really helping a lot since I’ve only been testing it for a few months.

    I will keep you posted regarding the progress of my research.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Pin It on Pinterest

Share This