I was asked recently on Facebook about consulting billing rates:
“Was wondering how you work your consulting business? Is it per project? Per month? etc. I have had a few people ask for my help and I just am not sure where to start.”
Great question. There are two methods for assessing your fair consultant billing rate, and both are important, the floor and the ceiling. But before we get into that, we have to answer a critical existing question.
What Have You Been Billing?
This is usually the painful part. We typically express billing rates or effective billing rates in currency per hour of time. So, our first step should be to understand what our rates are. Whether you do projects, hourly billing, etc. doesn’t matter; we just need to get to an understanding of what our rate is.
Let’s say you’ve got a handful of recent projects. Log what you earned for each project, and log the hours you invested:
What we see above are some wild variations in our billing example, from a minimum of $333 per hour to a maximum of $3,400 per hour. That’s a literal 10x discrepancy from minimum to maximum. So the question is… why? What was so different about these clients or projects in the toy example above that justified such huge variations in what you were charging per hour?
If we don’t know, then this would be a good time to find out. Knowing what makes one customer pay 10x more than another customer is vitally important, because it helps you understand some of your value. If you can identify more of the work that pays crazy good, then you can focus your marketing efforts on attracting more of that kind of work.
So, now that you know what your current billing rate is, let’s see where it fits in the grand scheme of things.
Your Floor Minimum Billing Rate
Here’s how to judge your minimum consulting billing rate. This is the rate you must charge in order for you to justify your time and the project you’re working on and is typically expressed in an hourly rate. First, you need to know what your mandatory annual income is, the money you must earn in order to be able to survive and reasonably thrive. As a consultant, there’s a good chance you will be a 1099 consultant as well, so you’ll need to budget between 30-50% extra for health insurance, self-employment tax, etc.
For example, let’s say you have $40,000 in actual expenses for the year, including rent, food, etc. If you’d like to make a copy, feel free to use this link to copy this Google Sheet for yourself. (choose File > Make A Copy in the Google Sheets interface)
Using the calculator above, I set a tax bracket of 25% for federal, 7% for state, and a healthcare cost estimated at 25% of all expenses. Before anything else, the total income I’d need in this example is $62,800.
Now here’s the part almost every consultant does wrong. They assume 100% utilization, meaning every hour they’re clocked into work, they’re doing billable work. That’s far, far, far from the truth. The reality is that consultants are lucky to get 50% utilization. If you’ve ever done business with an agency, the average billing rate is 3x the salary of the person doing the work; that 3x multiple translates into 33% billable time. The other 67% of your time will be spent building your business, marketing yourself, speaking, etc.
In the example above, that $62,800 in necessary income is $188,400 in what you must bill in total for the year.
Don’t forget things like time off. If you want to take time off – and you should – that must be budgeted as well. In the example above, I removed 80 hours of billable time, or two weeks’ vacation. Want to take more? Remove more billable hours. Live in a nation where there are minimum requirements for time off? Add that in.
Once you have your hours and the total amount you must bill, divide the two. Above, in order to meet expenses, grow the business, and take time off, I would need to bill $94.20 per hour in order to sustain a consulting business. This is my floor billing rate, the rate I must not bill under, or else I risk losing money and/or harming my ability to grow the business. Most large consulting agencies follow a similar model, either the 3x rule or maintaining 40% gross margin.
For individuals and small boutique consulting firms, I strongly recommend the 3x rule.
Don’t accept any project under that rate unless there’s some massive leverage that comes with the project, like the opportunity to move up the food chain somehow. If you’re billing a project with a fixed fee, decide how many hours it will take you to accomplish it, multiply times your hourly rate, and be sure to specify in your contract that the project is restricted to X hours, with additional hourly charges for every hour after that point.
Remember the exercise you just did? If any of your projects or clients are below your floor billing rate, those are clients or projects that, if ongoing, you either need to raise your rates on, or consider parting ways.
Your Ceiling Maximum Billing Rate
The ceiling is where you make the big money, but it’s much harder to judge, much harder to assess without a lot of experience.
Your ceiling rate is based on how much your work is worth to your client.
For example, let’s say you’ve been asked to speak at a conference and you’re a popular speaker. You know that you can put 50 butts in seats just by telling your fan base that you’ll be there. You know that the conference is charging $495 per ticket. Effectively, your value to the conference is $495 x 50, or $24,750. If you don’t speak, the conference may or may not fill those seats.
It’s reasonable, therefore, to ask for a percentage of that ticket fee as your pay. How much should you ask for? Some conferences are offering up to 50% of the ticket price as a commission in their affiliate program, so it’s reasonable to ask for that as your fee outright or in an affiliate program if you’ve got a great audience/community.
Think about the contrast between floor and ceiling in this example. If you charged your floor rate of $94.20/hour, even if you billed for an entire day (8 hours) for the conference, you’d only make $753 at your floor billing rate. If you got 50% of ticket under your affiliate program (assuming 50 seats at $495/seat), you’d get $12,375. That’s a gigantic difference, and it’s why you must find your ceiling as quickly as possible.
In order to develop a fair ceiling rate, you must know and understand deeply the industries and companies you’re serving so that you know the economic value of the work you’re providing. As another example, say you know a particular method for looking at Google Analytics, a way that can instantly increase the ROI of a company by 30%. If you know the company’s industry and know that 30% more in their digital marketing ROI is worth X, you can justify charging a percentage of X and explaining how your pricing works. In Alan Weiss’ excellent Value-Based Fees book, he recommends a 4:1 ROI fee; for every $4 in new revenue you help a business earn, you keep $1, or 25%.
A third example might be a graphic designer whose work increases website conversion from 2% to 5%. What does a 3% increase in conversion mean? Well, if the designer understands the companies they work with, they can say, “you’ll earn more with my design because my methods improve conversion from 2% to 5%, and that’s worth X to your company in additional revenue, thus my fee is 25% of X’s value over the first year my design will be in operation as long as my design hits 5% conversion. After that first year, 100% of the increased value will be profit to you“.
That’s the power of ceiling billing rates – it goes far beyond day labor rates because you know what your work is worth, and once you explain that to your clients, you stand a far better chance of earning more. Why? Because you demonstrate understanding of their business and the value you are providing, and you have a performance target built in. If your client reaches 5% website conversion, you get paid a large fee because you created the value they were seeking.
Finding your ceiling requires you to ask, ask, ask your customers what the impact of your work will be, and/or asking peers, colleagues, or even competitors what results they’ve generated. There’s no substitute for domain expertise or knowledge in finding your ceiling.
The Big Question
Now, from the exercise you did at the beginning: how far off is your current maximum billing rate from what you believe to be true about the market maximum billing rate? Are you netting more than what you estimate? Are you substantially under?
If you calculate that your impact for a client is in the millions of dollars and you’re charging them hundreds of dollars, then that’s a pretty good sign that it’s time to raise your rates.
On the other hand, if your current maximum exceeds what you think the theoretical maximum is, then congratulations: you are setting the realistic market maximum rate because that’s what you’re getting paid now.
Floor billing rates are typically expressed in hours – $50/hour, $500/hour. Ceiling billing rates are typically expressed as percentages of fees or flat budgets. This project will cost $25,000, this work will cost $5,000, etc.
You know you’re closer to your ceiling billing rate when you stop quoting hours.
Your goal in doing any kind of consulting is to achieve your ceiling billing rate as soon as practical, while never violating the floor rate. That means developing a strong, deep understanding of the value of your work to your clients and moving away from the floor where you’re just another hired hand whose work quality may or may not impact their business.
Disclosure: this post was first published in 2012 and has been revised several times since. The most recent revision adds current billing rate calculations.
You might also enjoy:
- Almost Timely News, 17 October 2021: Content Creation Hacks, Vanity Metrics, NFTs
- The Basic Truth of Mental Health
- How To Start Your Public Speaking Career
- What Content Marketing Analytics Really Measures
- You Ask, I Answer: Google Tag Manager and Google Analytics Integration?
Want to read more like this from Christopher Penn? Get updates here:
Get your copy of AI For Marketers