I’ll gently disagree with Chris Brogan’s idea about recycling blog posts yesterday. Go read it if you haven’t.
Welcome back.
Here’s why this is a bad idea. Senior master instructor Ken Savage of the Winchendon Martial Arts Center likes to compare life to a wheel on a wagon. Each year, the wheel turns around and you’re back to where you started. What we often fail to take notice of is the distance that the wheel has traveled in that year. Each year, we’re further down the path than the year before. Each birthday that rolls around is another year of travel, and a lot happens in that year. You learn a lot. You change. You grow. The wagon is in a different place, too. The terrain is different, the environment is different.
If I write a blog post in, say 2008, about something “evergreen” and then just repost it as is or link it up without changing it, I’m giving short shrift not only to my readers, but also to myself. By doing that, I’m failing to acknowledge that a lot has happened in 3 turns of the wheel and who I am today in 2011 should have even more insight, even more value to add.
If you want to recycle older stuff, especially stuff with no interactions or comments on it, take just a couple of minutes to polish it up, rewrite parts that have changed, and add in anything that you’ve gained from your experiences as the wheel has turned. Then take your old post, redirect it to preserve any inbound link juice, and let the world know about your newer, more updated perspective on things.
When you think about it in terms of real world recycling, the exact same thing happens. The old is crushed into raw materials, melted down, impurities extracted, and then reformed into something new. Don’t just hand someone a “used bottle” blog post – truly recycle it and give them something fresh.
You might also enjoy:
- Understand the Meaning of Metrics
- Retiring Old Email Marketing Strategies
- How To Set Your Consulting Billing Rates and Fees
- You Ask, I Answer: Google Tag Manager and Google Analytics Integration?
- What Content Marketing Analytics Really Measures
Want to read more like this from Christopher Penn? Get updates here:
 Get your copy of AI For Marketers |
Interesting take. I agree with you both. I started “recycling” posts about two months ago and have seen measurable increases in Retweets and blog traffic. It. Really. Works.
However, your point is well taken too. For that reason, I carefully selected the blog categories I wanted included in order to avoid this as much as possible. Nonetheless, I have to admit I’ve cringed a couple of times seeing one of my blog posts from two years ago shared because I know it needs to be freshened up.
One concern I have about your approach – you would need to make sure it’s different enough that you don’t get penalized for duplicate content, yes?
You actually 301 the old post entirely so the original content is gone.
Good point. Or I suppose you could also update the original post with a new date.
I think… that really this is like an issue with blog theme architecture.. how that imbues or attributes value in certain ways.. is there any reason blogs should be so much about your latest post versus one from 3 years ago? Why should you even have to recycle?
Might depend on what you blog about, or blogging style. I think the issue is we’ve inherited a way of looking at things.. and just sorta go along with it.Or what about principles of user centric design?This structural stuff imposes a whole lot of force onto the play ground, and that our strategic presumptions, and then brings all kinds of implications of how we are creating culture… all going mostly unexamined.But finally, why recycle, why not remix?
The idea of reworking it a bit makes sense. Recycling in the sense that we take our old stuff, melt it down, reshape it, and fashion it into something new implies crafting it to meet today’s needs.
I like the point, though, about improving link juice in the process.
With my consulting collaborative, we call this “remixing content” rather than recycling. It could be by making a long post shorter, a short post longer, turning it into a guest post on another blog, or updating and reposting an old, dated post with new stats, quotes, references. Straight recycling/reusing does seems a short shrift.